We have decided to discontinue the publication of preprints on our preprint server as of 1 March 2024. The publication culture within mathematics has changed so much due to the rise of repositories such as ArXiV (www.arxiv.org) that we are encouraging all institute members to make their preprints available there. An institute's repository in its previous form is, therefore, unnecessary. The preprints published to date will remain available here, but we will not add any new preprints here.
MiS Preprint
74/2017
Coarse-graining and the Blackwell Order
Johannes Rauh, Pradeep Kumar Banerjee, Eckehard Olbrich, Jürgen Jost, Nils Bertschinger and David Wolpert
Suppose we have a pair of information channels, $\kappa_{1},\kappa_{2}$, with a common input. The Blackwell order is a partial order over channels that compares $\kappa_{1}$ and $\kappa_{2}$ by the maximal expected utility an agent can obtain when decisions are based on the channel outputs. Equivalently, $\kappa_{1}$ is said to be Blackwell-inferior to $\kappa_{2}$ if and only if $\kappa_{1}$ can be constructed by garbling the output of $\kappa_{2}$. A related partial order stipulates that $\kappa_{2}$ is more capable than $\kappa_{1}$ if the mutual information between the input and output is larger for $\kappa_{2}$ than for $\kappa_{1}$ for any distribution over inputs. A Blackwell-inferior channel is necessarily less capable. However, examples are known where $\kappa_{1}$ is less capable than $\kappa_{2}$ but not Blackwell-inferior. We show that this may even happen when $\kappa_{1}$ is constructed by coarse-graining the inputs of $\kappa_{2}$. Such a coarse-graining is a special kind of "pre-garbling" of the channel inputs. This example directly establishes that the expected value of the shared utility function for the coarse-grained channel is larger than it is for the non-coarse-grained channel. This contradicts the intuition that coarse-graining can only destroy information and lead to inferior channels. We also discuss our results in the context of information decompositions.